Latest Food & Entertainment News

Support CraveDFW

Retro Movie Review: Thanksgiving Edition

FacebookInstagram

Christmas has a hundred movies and Thanksgiving has about six. That never seemed fair to me. The holiday is built for film: one table, too many people, a lot of history, and nowhere for anyone to go until the pie comes out. The best Thanksgiving movies aren’t really about turkey. They’re about family, the kind you love and the kind you survive.

Here are three worth watching this year, after the dishes are done and the house finally gets quiet.

Hannah and Her Sisters (1986)

Directed by Woody Allen. Starring Mia Farrow, Michael Caine, Dianne Wiest and Barbara Hershey. Rated PG-13, 1 hour 47 minutes.

If you only watch one, make it this one. Woody Allen built the whole film around Thanksgiving dinners at Hannah’s apartment in Manhattan, covering two years in the lives of three sisters and everyone orbiting them. It opens at one Thanksgiving and closes at another, and you can feel how much has changed in the room by the end.

Mia Farrow is Hannah, the steady one everyone leans on and nobody thinks to check on. Barbara Hershey is Lee, who lives with a gruff, brilliant painter played by Max von Sydow. Dianne Wiest is Holly, the sister who can’t land on a career and keeps borrowing money from Hannah to try another one. Michael Caine plays Hannah’s husband, Elliot, who falls hard for Lee and spends half the movie talking himself into and out of it.

Allen plays Mickey, Hannah’s ex-husband, a hypochondriac TV producer convinced every headache is the end. His storyline is the funniest thing in the film, and it leads to one of the best scenes Allen ever wrote, when a man at the end of his rope wanders into a movie theater showing the Marx Brothers and decides life might be worth sticking around for after all.

The Academy loved it. The film won three Oscars, for Caine, for Wiest and for Allen’s original screenplay. Nearly 40 years later, it still plays like a good novel. Every character gets a full life, and the Thanksgiving scenes feel like real ones, loud and warm and a little tense.

Home for the Holidays (1995)

Directed by Jodie Foster. Starring Holly Hunter, Robert Downey Jr., Anne Bancroft and Charles Durning. Rated PG-13, 1 hour 43 minutes.

This is the one to put on with the whole family, as long as the whole family can take a joke. Jodie Foster directed it, her second film behind the camera, and she cast it about as well as anyone could.

Holly Hunter plays Claudia Larson, a single mother who loses her job, kisses her boss on the way out the door, catches a cold and then flies home to Baltimore for Thanksgiving anyway. Her teenage daughter, played by a young Claire Danes, stays behind. Waiting for Claudia are her parents, Anne Bancroft and Charles Durning, who are wonderful together, a couple who have been married long enough to drive each other crazy and still mean it.

Then there’s Robert Downey Jr. as Tommy, the brother who shows up late with a friend nobody expected. Foster let Downey improvise, and you can tell. He’s loose and funny and a little out of control, and he steals every scene he’s in. The dinner itself goes off the rails in the way real holiday dinners do, with old grudges coming out over the side dishes and a turkey that does not stay on the platter.

Critics were split when it came out. Time has been kinder. It’s a messy movie about a messy family, and that’s exactly why it holds up.

The Ice Storm (1997)

Directed by Ang Lee. Starring Kevin Kline, Joan Allen, Sigourney Weaver and Christina Ricci. Rated R, 1 hour 52 minutes.

Save this one for later in the night, after the kids are in bed. It’s the most serious of the three and the best made.

Ang Lee directed it from James Schamus’s adaptation of the Rick Moody novel. It’s set over Thanksgiving weekend in 1973 in the suburbs of Connecticut, with Watergate playing on every television and two families coming apart in slow motion. Kevin Kline and Joan Allen play Ben and Elena Hood, a married couple who stopped talking a long time ago. Ben is having an affair with the neighbor, Janey Carver, played with an ice-cold elegance by Sigourney Weaver.

The kids are drifting too. Tobey Maguire plays the Hoods’ son, Paul, home from prep school. Christina Ricci plays their daughter, Wendy, and Elijah Wood plays the Carvers’ quiet son, Mikey. The adults spend the weekend chasing the new freedoms of the decade, and the children are mostly left to figure things out on their own.

Then the storm hits, and the whole town freezes over. Lee shoots the ice like it’s something beautiful and dangerous at the same time, which is the whole movie in a single image. The final half hour is as quiet and heartbreaking as anything from the 1990s.

Weaver won the BAFTA for supporting actress, and the film took the screenplay prize at Cannes. It’s not a feel-good holiday movie. It is a great one, and it might send you back to the table the next morning a little more grateful for the people sitting around it.

Pour another glass, find a spot on the couch and let the leftovers wait.

More Retro Movie Reviews


Discover more from CraveDFW

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

More from CraveDFW

See all

The Friday Edition

The week’s best from CraveDFW, in your inbox every Friday morning.